So. It was high time to get things in order. I decided to expand my system to two binders: one for the recipes I use on a consistent basis, and one for those recipes I only use occasionally. I also pulled out some colorful dividers so that I could better organize my everyday recipes.
For meal planning purposes, I have a list of all my main dishes. Then on the clipboard I have my menu plan for the week, and I put my recipes for the week with the plan. My intention is to start putting back the previous week's recipe pages at the time when I plan meals for the coming week. Here's hoping!
Check out Organizing Junkie for other ideas on getting your recipes in order.